News Summary and Comment:
Today I lead with a story broken by Canadians for Accountability. It seems that some of our board members spotted some suspicious sole source contracts involving the Public Service Commission of Canada. An Access to Information Act request was made, which yielded documents demonstrating that not only were these contracts very juicy ($21,000 for the first year, but extensible for three more years) but also that contractors had been consulted in preparing the specs for the Advance Contract Award Notices used to hire them. This, of course, made it impossible for them to lose. The PSC is arguing that this is normal, but we’re not buying it. And even if it were, it would still be unethical.
In another key bit of news, the Manitoba Hydro whistleblower has been denied intervenor status in the Public Utilities Board hearing in September. The whistleblower was hired by Manitoba Hydro in 2004 to help them with risk management. At the time, they were hemorrhaging cash and were using risk management decision management software from the 1980s.
During her work, she determined that mismanagement had caused the unnecessary loss of about a half billion dollars. These losses, of course, were being passed on to Manitobans by way of rate increases. In addition, she determined that there was a serious risk of blackouts in the province.
When she reported this, the CEO fired her 24 hours after notifying him. Nothing happened at first – until the media got hold of it in late 2008. This caused a furor and sent the government into defensive mode. Well it should, too: Premier Selinger had been the minister responsible for Manitoba Hydro a few years earlier.
Naturally, it didn’t take long for things to get nasty. Manitoba Hydro has been using the usual tricks played on whistleblowers: a bogus and flawed investigation into her findings, smears on her character in a gratuitous, over-the-top and disingenuous (if not outright dishonest) affidavit posted on the Internet, and violations of publication bans that seem to me to be intended to hurt her reputation and future contract opportunities. And, since they can’t use the old disloyalty chestnut, they’re using another oldie-but-goodie: it wasn’t her role to do risk management, they are saying. Not only is that irrelevant, it’s ludicrous when one considers what she was hired for.
To make matters worse, it seems that oversight agencies are joining in. First off, the Manitoba Ombudsman has failed to act on the violation of the publication ban and seems to have no interest in investigating what look like violations of the Manitoba Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. They also refuse to indemnify her for her legal expenses, making this a real David and Goliath battle.
And now the Public Utilities Board, which is holding rate hearings in September, has not only refused to grant the whistleblower intervenor status, it is insisting that she redact a 400 100 page report in less than three weeks – after Manitoba Hydro was given unlimited time to file its reports, make presentations to defend their position. Hydro has missed deadline after deadline, but the whistleblower, who isn’t even under contract, is supposed to file all her findings in one week. This is apparently an attempt to make it impossible for her to debunk the position being put forward by Manitoba Hydro management.
Ever wonder why there are so few Canadian whistleblowers? Well, this is why. If I were a Manitoban, I’d be pretty angry.
Just one more thing worthy of comment today – I’ve put together a list of articles that have been printed on Chander Grover’s case in the South Asia Mail. It’s worth you while to see how far a government agency will go to win, even when it’s wrong, and even when ordered to make restitution.
See you Thursday.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Canadians for Accountability Reports Suspicious Contracts to Treasury Board
Manitoba Hydro Whistleblower Denied Status at Key Inquiry
Federal Ministerial Staffers Interfering with Information Requests Again
New Afghan Detainee Documents Cause More Controversy
Protest Held Outside Rights and Democracy
N.S. MLA Expenses Scandal Claims another Politician
Transport Canada Accused of Hiding Documents Related to Port Stanley
A Four-part Series on the Racial Discrimination of Dr. Grover by the NRC
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Canadians for Accountability Reports Suspicious Contracts to Treasury Board
Federal agency accused of sole-sourcing contracts
CTV News, March 28, 2010
Summary: A federal agency that’s supposed to ensure government hiring is fair and transparent is being accused of cooking four employment contracts. The Public Service Commission of Canada issued four sole-source contracts last fall after allowing the favoured candidates to vet their own job descriptions beforehand, says a public watchdog group. And that amounts to stacking the deck so that any other potential candidates don’t stand a chance, charges Canadians for Accountability.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Manitoba Hydro Whistleblower Denied Status at Key Inquiry
Whistleblower denied status at PUB hearing
Winnipeg Free Press, March 14, 2010
Summary: A New York consultant who blew the whistle on possible financial risks facing Manitoba Hydro won’t be at the table when the Public Utilities Board (PUB) starts its mega hearing into power rates later this year. The regulator ruled Friday that the whistleblower — whose identity cannot be revealed because of a court order — will not be given intervener status at the hearing, as she requested earlier this month.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Federal Ministerial Staffers Interfering with Requests for Information Again
Tory aide tried to suppress $5-million Olympic ad bill
Globe and Mail, March 29, 2010
Summary: A senior Conservative official repeatedly intervened last month to try and suppress the revelation that Ottawa spent $5-million on a TV advertising blitz surrounding the Vancouver Olympics, new records show.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
New Afghan Detainee Documents Cause More Controversy
Afghans routinely executed detainees: soldier
CBC News, March 26, 2010
Summary: A Canadian soldier has alleged that Afghan authorities routinely executed detainees his unit handed over to them, newly released documents show.
Détenus afghans: de nouvelles allégations inquiétantes, selon l’opposition
La Presse, March 26, 2010
Summary: De nouvelles allégations contenues dans les documents déposés jeudi à la Chambre des communes renforcent la nécessité de tenir une enquête publique sur le dossier des détenus afghans, estime l’opposition à Ottawa.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Protest Held Outside Rights and Democracy
Groups demand Rights & Democracy inquiry
CBC News, March 26, 2010
Summary: Human rights groups staged a protest outside the Montreal offices of Rights & Democracy on Friday, demanding a public inquiry into inner turmoil at the taxpayer-funded organization that promotes human rights and democratic values. The protesters claim a public inquiry is the only way to shed light on allegations of government interference in the organization, which was created under Brian Mulroney’s Conservative government.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
N.S. MLA Expenses Scandal Claims another Politician
NDP suspends MLA
Chronicle-Herald (Halifax), March 26, 2010
Summary: Saying they no longer trust a fellow MLA, the New Democrats have suspended backbencher Trevor Zinck from caucus because of “persistent” problems with constituency bills.
Spending rules tightened for Nova Scotia MLAs
Chronicle-Herald (Halifax), March 27, 2010
Summary: The Nova Scotia government introduced legislation Friday that it says would tighten oversight and make spending by provincial politicians more open by posting their expenses online.
—————————————————————————————————————————–
Transport Canada Accused of Hiding Documents Related to Port Stanley
Transport Canada neglects Port Stanley
London Free Press, March 27, 2010
Summary: A future regional economic engine is at stake with Central Elgin’s negotiations with Transport Canada over Port Stanley’s harbour. That’s why this story should upset you. (Letter to the editor)
—————————————————————————————————————————–
A Four-part Series on the Racial Discrimination of Dr. Grover by the NRC
State-sponsored Racial Discrimination in Canada: Racial Discrimination of Dr. Grover by the NRC (Part 1)
Is racism in Canada a reality or a relic of the past? (Part 2)
A Culture of Abuse and Torture – Canadian Government Style (Part 3)
Is the Office of the Auditor General of Canada reliable? (Part 4)
Other related articles in the South Asia Mail:
March 20, 2010: http://www.southasiamail.com/mainnews.php?id=7955
March 22, 2010: http://www.southasiamail.com/mainnews.php?id=7983
March 26, 2010: http://www.southasiamail.com/mainnews.php?id=8032
March 28, 2010: http://www.southasiamail.com/mainnews.php?id=8058
March 29, 2010: http://www.southasiamail.com/blog/